November 8, 2026 • The 24th Sunday After Pentecost • Proper 27
Wisdom of Solomon 6:12-16 | Psalm 70 | 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18 | Matthew 25:1-13
The look in her eyes told me I had deceived her. How could you? they screamed silently. The tears were swelling, her jaw set in a familiar expression of controlled rage and determination to withhold what was on the tip of her tongue. She whirled away from me, storming off as if the sky would fall where we stood, and it could fall on me, as far as she was concerned. Our friends weren’t coming over that evening, and after a day spent cleaning the house with great expectation, the change in plans obviously meant the world was coming to an end. Her mother and all of time and space had let her down. There was nothing I could do.
Thankfully, Jesus is not so helpless. Our good shepherd who guides us through dark valleys and to green pastures, our mother hen who gathers us under her wings, Jesus gives Christians every reason to expect that we will be received into the kingdom of heaven. When we read and hear the gospel lesson from Matthew today, however, we might be left wondering if maybe there is more to this entry to the kingdom of heaven than we anticipated. Will our expectations be met or our hopes dashed?
The disciples gathered around Jesus, attentive to his words shaping the parables that bore with them the importance of what was to come. “The kingdom of heaven will be like this,” he said, and all eyes and ears are fixed on the one who knows. Of course! Bridesmaids waiting on the bridegroom! When the Son of Man returns, won’t we all be waiting with eager anticipation? But…the bridegroom will be delayed, not everyone will be ready, the door will get shut, and some will be excluded, fools that they are.
Perhaps we feel validated by this parable, justified for what we’ve done to be prepared for the coming of Christ. We’re ready, and the foolish who haven’t gotten their life together, well, that’s the way it is. You’re in or out. There is certainty in our expectation, clarity from what Jesus has described. We can live with that.
Or maybe we need more time to process.
I imagine there are more of us who feel troubled at Jesus’s parable, confused at how our loving God would or could create such exclusion to the kingdom of heaven. Where’s the unconditional love, the acceptance of who we are, and compassion for what we’re going through? We are all created in God’s image and yearn for wholeness, a completion promised in our unity with our Creator. We hope for such a reunion. Could we be excluded for such a trivial thing as not having enough oil in our lamp?
It depends on what the oil and lamp represent. It is a parable, after all.
The Thessalonians in their beginner’s zeal and enthusiasm anticipated the coming of the Son of Man at any moment. As time passed and people died, they were very anxious that the believers who had died would not be caught up in the bodily resurrection to be a part of the New Creation in the reign of God. Paul pastorally assured them that the dead would rise first, then the living, putting their fears aside so they could carry on in their life and labor for the building up of community and the glory of God. In a sense, Paul helped manage their expectations, clarifying their certainty so that they could return to hopeful anticipation, for truly they were not a people without hope.
So where is our hope in the parable of the bridesmaids? Surely Jesus meant to assure us, too?
Consider more closely the bridesmaids who eagerly await the bridegroom. The members of the wedding party have roles to serve, expectations to fulfill, even as they anticipate partaking in the wedding banquet. As they wait . . . and wait, even the wise and well-prepared sleep alongside their foolish counterparts. At first sight of the bridegroom, all are awakened, and the reality of their situation plays out. Some make it through the door before it is shut on those who weren’t ready, who didn’t have enough oil for their lamps, at least not in time.
We don’t know if there was any discussion amongst the disciples on the parable, but I imagine no one went without an extra flask of oil on hand. We might wonder: couldn’t the bridesmaids have shared? Couldn’t one lamp light the way for two or three? Literally, perhaps, but figuratively, not quite.
This lesson follows the Feast of All Saints’, a baptismal occasion as one of our major feast days. In our baptism we receive the oil that seals us in the Holy Spirit and marks us as Christ’s own forever. That is an indelible mark of belonging. We are forever known to Christ, having professed not only our renunciation of evil but also our belief and acceptance of Jesus Christ as our Savior. We mark that with oil. And we are given a candle as a symbol of the light of Christ we bear to the world. The spiritual gift of faith keeps our light–our lamp–burning brightly. Our faith fuels–like oil for the flame–all that we do that prepares us for the reign of God, even if it seems like we are forever waiting. Day in and day out, our actions give body, shape, and meaning to the faith we carry because we still hope for that which God has promised. We still profess our faith, and as the wise bridesmaids show us, the faith, the oil we have is ours alone.
But there were ten bridesmaids in the parable. There was community. When we are so-gathered, we are responsible for ourselves, and there is the opportunity to share and learn, to pay attention to one another and make sure that everyone has what they need. Even so, as we live our lives faithfully, we often find that we cannot give our faith to others. We can’t make another’s actions mean something for them. They have to have accepted the grace of God for themselves. The five wise bridesmaids made it through the door with the groom, but the other five were left at the closed door. They call out, “Lord, Lord, open to us,” but they are met with the reply, “I do not know you.” If we stand at the door and knock, we need to be recognizable, known to our Savior. Matthew writes earlier in chapter 7 that Jesus says, “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven” (Matt. 7:21).
We may not know the depth of the will of God, but we do know what God asks of us: to love God with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength, and to love our neighbors as ourselves. Rooted in our belief, our practice will look like acting justly, loving mercy, and walking humbly through every day while we wait for the coming of the reign of God. The unconditional love of God is available to all, and that love asks something of us, relational as it is. Some of us may have missed out on formation or skipped baptismal preparation and set our expectations on a relationship with no judgment nor accountability for what is required of one who takes on the life of Christ. In our life together, however, we can, like the Thessalonians, encourage one another so that we know about the grace of God, the way to receive that grace, and how to keep our lamps burning brightly.
Part of what we practice here every week is our preparation for the heavenly banquet. Our tradition, our Mother Church, is getting us ready for when all are gathered into God’s presence and the time for the New Creation has come. Every Sunday we share in God’s Word, hear the Good News, profess our faith, confess our sins, care for one another in prayer, and feast at the heavenly banquet with the Presence of Christ. Then we go into the world to love and serve the Lord, tangibly drawing the kingdom of heaven nearer with coffee served, warmth shared, suffering relieved. And one day we will find ourselves at the door and cross the threshold into everlasting glory.
With spiritual imagination, picture the look in our eyes when we behold the kingdom of heaven, recognized as the child of God we are. Beyond all we could ever ask or imagine, the fullness of God’s glory fills all time and space, and we may find ourselves thinking, “How could you?” not in accusation but in astonishment as we surrender to the love for which we always hoped. And that hope does not disappoint us.
~The Rev. Sara Milford
[1] https://www.episcopalchurch.org/lectionary/peter-paul/